☢ test - Í
properly admitted defendant’s spontaneous statement, “I’m guilty. I’m guilty.” Statement was made in Magistrate Court first appearance hearing. “At this hearing, Judge Lazaros began reading a checklist advising Simmons of his charges and his rights. No one initiated any questioning of Simmons.” Defendant was unrepresented by counsel at the time. “‘Any statement given freely and voluntarily without any compelling influences is, of course admissible in evidence.’ (Citation and punctuation omitted.) Rhode Island v. Innis, 446 U.S. 291, 307(II)(A), 100 S.Ct. 1682, 64 L.Ed.2d 297 (1980). ‘Voluntary, spontaneous outbursts that are not made in response to any form of custodial questioning or interrogation are admissible at trial.’ (Citations and punctuation omitted.) State v. Davison, 280 Ga. 84, 87–88(2), 623 S.E.2d 500 (2005). There was no error in the admission at trial of Simmons's statement of guilt made at his first appearance hearing.” Accord, Thompson v. State , 295 Ga. 96, 757 S.E.2d 846 (April 22, 2014) (defendant’s spontaneous statements, overheard by officer guarding him after defendant terminated interrogation, properly admitted). Anguiano v. State, 313 Ga.App. 449, 721 S.E.2d 652 (December 28, 2011). Convictions for attempted child molestation and enticement affirmed; trial court properly denied motion to suppress non- Mirandized statements made by defendant to television correspondent for “Dateline NBC.” Defendant was caught in internet child molestation sting set up by television producers, with knowledge of sheriff’s department. “According to [Sheriff’s Lieutenant] Armbrust's testimony, no law enforcement officers were visible to Anguiano when he arrived at the house; Anguiano had no contact with law enforcement until after he exited the house; and the arresting officers left the carport room and took position outside the residence only after Anguiano had already gone inside. Armbrust testified that he had no conversations with [television correspondent] Hansen at all; that the police officers ‘didn't have any direct contact with what NBC was to do’; and that the police had no prior arrangement with Chris Hansen as to whether Hansen would interview Anguiano at all or, if an interview took place, what questions Hansen might ask. Based on his familiarity with the television show, however, Armbrust anticipated that the event would be videotaped and that an interview with the suspect would take place.” Trial court found that the reporter “was not acting as an agent of the police” despite defendant’s contention “that he was ‘in custody’ … because Hansen was working on a joint venture run by NBC, [the show’s producer] PJ and the sheriff’s office; and because, as it turned out, Anguiano was arrested once he left the house.” Reporter was not police agent. “‘ Miranda warnings are not a prerequisite to the admission of statements made by a defendant to persons other than law enforcement officers or their agents.’ (Citations omitted.) Bethea v. State, 251 Ga. 328, 330–331(7) (304 S.E.2d 713) (1983) (statements made by defendant while incarcerated to his Army commanding officer were admissible). See Harper v. State, 249 Ga. 519, 528(4)(b) (292 S.E.2d 389) (1982) (female who visited defendant in jail was not acting as agent of FBI even though FBI knew she was visiting and paid her travel expenses). In determining whether Hansen was acting as an agent of the state, we again look at the totality of the circumstances. In re: T.A.G., 292 Ga.App. 48, 51(1)(b) (663 S.E.2d 392) (2008), citing Cook v. State, 270 Ga. 820, 827(2) (514 S.E.2d 657) (1999) (issue of ‘custody’ where challenged statements were made by incarcerated defendant to his father, an FBI agent). Although the sheriff's office initially invited PJ and NBC into the county and identified a house for NBC to rent, it was NBC that arranged to rent the house, paid the rent, and directed the film production. The scheme to engage on-line predators was devised by PJ, not by police; and the on-line chats which lured Anguiano to the house were conducted by PJ without police monitoring, supervision, or direction. No one at NBC or PJ was paid by the sheriff's office; the sheriff's office did not authorize them to act nor did it direct their actions, in particular with regard to the questions Hansen chose to ask in the interview or even as to whether such an interview would take place at all; and the interviewer, Hansen, was found by the court to be ‘an aggressive television newsreporter pursuing his professional employment[, and] not involved in law enforcement or employed by any state agency.’ Further, police were not present at Hansen's interview with Anguiano; indeed, they were not even in the building. The mere fact that there was cooperation between the private entities involved and the police does not by itself create an agency relation. See Roberson v. State, 265 Ga. 658, 659(1) (461 S.E.2d 212) (1995) (defendants' statements made in media interview were admissible even though interview could not have occurred without police cooperation, where police had no control over the questions posed by reporter). We conclude that there was evidence to support the trial court's finding that Hansen was not an agent of the state.” Bone v. State, 311 Ga.App. 390, 715 S.E.2d 789 (August 15, 2011). Conviction for possession of methamphetamine affirmed; trial court properly ruled that officer’s question about ownership of car wasn’t interrogation “designed to lead to incriminating evidence, but rather to garner information needed to most efficiently remove the car from the side of the road.” Defendant was already under arrest for obstruction and possession of meth when he told officer that “he gave somebody drugs so that he could use the car.” Hale v. State, 310 Ga.App. 363, 714 S.E.2d 19 (June 30, 2011). Convictions for DUI and improper passing affirmed; defendant was in custody when alco-sensor administered, but still admissible without Miranda warnings because defendant asked for test himself. Arrest. “[B]ecause Hale was informed of the officer's intent to place him under arrest,
Made with FlippingBook Ebook Creator